Abstract
Colloid cysts are uncommon benign lesions. There is a lack of consensus regarding the preferred surgical strategy for colloid cyst resection; the technique with the optimal rates of remission, recurrence, mortality, and complications is debatable.
To determine surgical outcomes, we performed a systematic review of the published literature on Colloid cysts. Eligible studies (n = 63) with a prospective or retrospective evaluation of endoscopic or microscopic resection of third ventricle colloid cysts were included, which contained data describing extents of resection, seizures, meningitis, and tumor recurrence. A total of 3143 patients (1741 microscopically and 1402 endoscopically operated) were included in the final analysis.
According to the results of the meta-analysis, there was a higher rate of gross total resection (GTR) (98.15% versus 91.29%, p = 0.00), need for shunting (4.75% versus 1.46%, p = 0.04), postoperative complications (20.68% versus 10.42%, P = 0.03), mean operating time (194.18 versus 113.04 min), and duration of hospitalization (7.85 versus 4.69 days) for microscopic resection compared with endoscopic resection. While endoscopic resection is associated with a higher rate of cyst recurrence (1.78% versus 0.00%, P = 0.00), there was no difference in reoperation rate (0.49% for endoscopic versus 0.09% for microscopic resection).
Microsurgical resection of third ventricle colloid cysts was associated with a higher rate of GTR and a lower rate of recurrence, while there was a lower rate of postoperative complications, duration of surgery, and shorter hospitalization period in the endoscopic group.
•Microsurgical technique has greater colloid cyst GTR rate compared to endoscopic resection technique.•Lower recurrence rate and reoperation rate of microsurgical technique than the endoscopic technique.•Higher rates of shunt dependency, complications, and mortality in the microsurgical surgery than endoscopic technique.
