Abstract
Defenses of offensive speech typically include a distancing disclaimer, highlighting the separation between the person offering the defense and the offensive content itself.1 Consider, for example, the well-worn quotation widely misattributed to Voltaire: “I disagree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.”2 In this view, it is the principle, not the substance, of the speech that deserves respect. This view may be grounded in the belief, or some combination of beliefs, that one person’s “bad” speech is another person’s “good” speech;3 that even avowedly bad speech helps produce, or at least sharpen, good speech;4 that because the line between bad and good speech is a difficult one to draw, censorship is likely to stifle or chill good speech as well as bad speech;5 and/or that even if lines